‘Sceptical yet supportive’ - new data highlights low public understanding of charity

Olivia Miller
Pixabay :

A new study by Dr Beth Breeze of the University of Kent and Professor John Mohan of the University of Birmingham highlights long-standing low levels of public understanding of the role and purpose of charity, despite equally long-standing high levels of giving.

Charities in England and Wales spend considerable sums of money – up to £70 billion a year – but where this money comes from, and where it goes, are little understood.

During the current COVID-19 crisis there has been an unprecedentedly high response to fundraising efforts for NHS charities, notably the £26m raised by 99-year old war veteran Captain Tom Moore and the £33m raised by the BBC’s ‘Big Night In’ telethon. Despite such evident public generosity, there are ongoing debates about the ‘right role’ for charity in relation to state provision, and concerns are frequently raised about ‘poor practice’ in UK charities.

In their study, published in the journal History and Policy, Dr Breeze and Professor Mohan present evidence from previous studies (1947, 1991 and 2015) which show striking consistency across 70 years in terms of: a lack of detailed public knowledge about the charity sector; ongoing debates about the scope and limits of governmental responsibility and charitable initiative; widespread concern about waste and duplication of charitable efforts; and an enduring sense of frustration with fundraising tactics. They therefore highlight the need to be aware of the existence of a significant and enduring paradox: the reliance of British charity on sceptical but nonetheless supportive donors.

Dr Breeze, Director of Kent’s Centre for Philanthropy, said: ‘Charities are often subject to vigorous criticism and very negative newspaper headlines. As with previous crises, it is likely that current support will soon turn into criticism, for example of how quickly the funding is spent, and on what. We hope this research helps to provide some context that these concerns are long-standing, and that we all need to better appreciate the reality of how charitable income is raised and distributed.’

Professor Mohan said: ‘Levels of charitable giving have shown considerable stability, suggesting that there is sustained popular support for donating. Long-run trends show that the proportion of households giving to charity, and the amounts they give, fluctuate very little – and American data shows that this is true for most of the 20th century.’

Their article ‘Supportive yet Sceptical: Understanding public attitudes to charity’ is available here: http://www.historyandpolicy.org/policy-papers/papers/sceptical-yet-supportive-understanding-public-attitudes-to-charity